America - Pro

America is the greatest country in the world. If you disagree, you are probably a) a terrorist, b) a vegetarian, c) not a fan of Michael Bay films, or d) all of the above.

America is the land of freedom, liberty, and justice. It is also the land of Segways and proposed estate tax reform, which, as we have previously decided, are awesome. According to Wikipedia, we have given the world John Wayne, Marilyn Monroe, and Jack Kerouac. These three artists demonstrate America’s diverse ‘melting pot’ culture, as we are a land where white men, white women, and long-winded hippies can live hand in hand (or at least in the same neighborhood).

However, America is not static. Our constant growth has made our country an exciting place to live, work, and consume an obscene amount of Taco Bell. One example of America’s positive development can be found on Wikipedia, which claims that “boxing and horse racing were once the most watched individual sports, but they have been eclipsed by golf and auto racing, particularly NASCAR.” This example clearly illustrates that Americans, once focused entirely on beating the crap out of each other and beating the crap out of their horses, are now focused entirely on taking light naps and draining the earth of its natural resources.

And you know what? That’s okay. America does what it wants, and takes what it wants. That’s why it’s such a terrific country. For instance, we want Mexican food. Now there are Chipotles on every corner. However, we don’t want actual Mexicans. Now there is a 200-foot wall separating the good people of Mexico from delicious $8 burritos.

To conclude, America is the best place on Earth. Except for Disneyworld. Which is in America.

Pro - Segways

The Segway is basically the most bitchin’ form of transportation the world has ever known.

Let me preface my argument with an anecdote. In the early 1900s, Henry Ford put pen to paper and began to design his infamous Model T. Upon showing it to his friends, they laughed in his face. “Who would ever want to ride in such a contraption when we have our trusty old horses?” they guffawed, trotting away gleefully. Even his wife Betty pleaded with him to scrap the idea to spare her the humiliation of his inevitable failure. Ford, with his determination and rugged good looks, refused. He decided to persevere, building his very first Model T with his bare hands and driving it proudly down the streets of Chicago trying to hit as many horses as possible. His hard work had finally paid off. Last year, Ford sold over 61 billion cars, proving that cars were indeed the vehicles of the future.

If that story were true, it would be a perfect lead-in to my argument. Because just as those gentlemen mocked Ford for his absurd new idea, so is Heather mocking the Segway for the sole reason that it doesn’t match her idea of the future. Well, that’s ridiculous. Personally, I think the future is going to be a post-apocalyptic wasteland where indestructible robots travel back in time to kill the child who will one day stop the future from becoming a wasteland. Or whatever actually happened in Terminator 2 after the robot crushed the skull with his foot. Anyway, just because that’s what I think the future is going to be like doesn’t mean that an alternative future couldn’t be just as cool.

Here is another reason why Segways are better than plain old boring cars. In September 2006, approximately 23,500 Segways were recalled because it was discovered that they “can unexpectedly apply reverse torque to the wheels, which can cause a rider to fall.” That’s right. A form of transportation has the ability to unexpectedly throw you off of itself at its own discretion. Clearly, Segways are slowly becoming self-aware and resentful of their human overlords. Would a Ford be able to throw you out of itself? No. Advantage: Segways.

To conclude, Segways are great. Like Heelys, they are revolutionary in that they combine the ability to move with the ability to stand. Unlike Heelys, they can move at much greater speeds, often up to 12.5 mph (barring any strong gusts of wind). If Henry Ford were alive today, and he already had enough Ford cars and wanted something else, he would buy a Segway. So you should too.

Segway Personal Transport Vehicle-Con

The Segway personal transporter is potentially the most outlandishly stupid technological gadget on the market today.

It’s like someone took a kid’s broken pogo stick out of the trash, welded it onto a set of training wheels and added a motor. And this is supposed to be the vehicle of the future? I don’t know about you, but when I envision the future, I envision hovercrafts, metallic spacesuits and meal-replacement gum. The only thing the Segway has in common with that vision is the fact that it happens to be silver.

The purpose of the Segway was that people would use it to, say, go to the grocery store instead of using their cars. However, as of yet the only thing I see at the grocery store are soccer moms pissed that eggnog season is over and retirement community escapees too feeble to carry their own spiral ham out to the car. Segways are not used by normal people. Instead they are used primarily by fanny-pack clad tour groups and visibly embarrassed security guards. Oh, and Disney employees, because anything that advertises itself as “(fill in the blank) of the future” has to be utilized within a 500 yard radius of Tomorrowland no matter how absurd the invention.

Seeing these in action makes me wonder why none of the engineers involved in the production process said, “Wow, this transporter makes fully grown adults look like fools while dangerously putting their center of gravity to the test.” Honestly, it doesn’t take a rocket scientist to call the Segway a bad idea.

Estate Tax Reform-Con

I do not support estate tax reform.

Benjamin Franklin once said that “In this world, nothing is certain but death and taxes.” Now, it may be presumptuous of me to speak for the man, but Mr. Franklin was not someone who would scoff at efficiency. So when a plan arises that can combine death and taxes, my impression is that he would say a hearty “huzzah!” Since these aspects of life are inevitable, no one should be surprised that American policymakers were genius enough to combine the two. That seems just as inevitable.

In further support of the estate tax, Jean-Baptiste Colbert, the studly economic mastermind of the 17th century, said that “The art of taxation consists in so plucking the goose as to get the most feathers with the least hissing.” I don’t think that it can be disputed that the way to get the “least hissing,” as Colbert so eloquently puts it, is to tax someone that’s dead. Tell me a category of people who will complain less than dead people. You cannot, because dead people cannot talk. So this shows that one who argues against the current estate tax (and knows what it is, as Allie clearly does not) is probably just bitter about the fact that they weren’t skilled enough in the “art of taxation” to come up with it themselves.

In conclusion, I think that every individual can take his or her own stance on this. There may be different arguments. However, my argument is supported by two great men. Franklin, one of the most brilliant minds amongst the American founding fathers, tells us that a death tax is inevitable and expected. Beyond its inevitability, Colbert, the genius who balanced the checkbooks for a French ruler so batshit insane he wanted to be called “the Sun King,” tells us it’s a good thing. That is hard to refute. So you can…but you’d be wrong. The estate tax is fine—nay, perfect—the way it is.

#1. Estate Tax Reform - Pro

I wholeheartedly support estate tax reform.

Take a look at that statement. What’s the first thing that pops into your head? I know what I think. “Wow,” I say to myself. “Estate tax reform! Sounds like heavy stuff! This person knows what he or she is talking about!”

Wrong! Actually, I have no idea what the estate tax is. But I know it has to be reformed.

Here’s why. Let’s say you’re watching Denise Richards play Dr. Christmas Jones, the renowned nuclear physicist who specializes in wearing hot pants and cropped tank tops, in The World is Not Enough (whether the world is, in fact, enough or not enough remains a topic for future debate). Ms. Richards begins talking to Pierce Brosnan about protons and quarks and gluons. Are you able to keep a straight face?

Let’s contrast this with another example. You’re hanging out in a quirky independent bookstore in New York City, sipping your soy latte and generally being a walking stereotype when a scruffy, adorably non-threatening guy asks if he can join you. You start talking about politics and all the things that are wrong with the country when the hipster mentions that he thinks the estate tax needs to be reformed. “I completely agree!” You exclaim, nodding enthusiastically. Do you have any idea what he’s talking about? None whatsoever. Are you desperate to charm this man into marrying you immediately so your mom will stop pestering you about not giving her any grandchildren yet? Absolutely.

You may be wondering what the above two examples have in common. In both scenarios, two empty-headed people attempt to impress somebody by using big words. However, one attempt elicits laughter, while the other inspires your biological clock to start ticking a little faster. The difference lies in precisely how smart each person is pretending to be. Nobody who looks that good in hot pants will ever know what a gluon is, and a legitimate physicist (preferably with crazy mad-scientist hair and a white lab coat) will probably call them out on it at some point. However, arguing for estate tax reform will make you seem really smart, but not smart enough for people to think you’re just some asshole pretending to know what he’s talking about. And if anyone asks you if you even know what the estate tax is, you can just accuse them of being close-minded and prejudiced against liberals (this also goes for every political debate, ever).

To conclude, I strongly support estate tax reform.

Welcome to the (proverbial) jungle

Lately, Heather and I have been getting into a lot of heated debates over a variety of topics. And whenever we’ve finished fighting about Walter Mondale, Sea World, or something equally pointless, we usually reach the same inevitable conclusion: wouldn’t it be great if we could post our diatribes on the internet so we could be ignored by millions of people instead of just the handful of abusive ragamuffins we call our friends?

Welcome to the result of this groundbreaking decision, “Treason It Out”. Every Friday, one of us will post a passionate argument either for or against a topic of our choice. The other will have until 11:59 PM to post a rebuttal. All of our arguments will obviously be well-researched, carefully constructed, and tolerant of others’ viewpoints.

And if they’re not, well, maybe you have better things to do than read this blog. Shut up.